Anyone else getting tired of the Penn State head coaching rumors? After all, the University trustees fired Joe Paterno nearly two months ago! In the interim, just about everyone has been suggested by the media, bloggers, and/or delusional Penn State fans as the next head coach. A few coaches with current or former ACC experience have been part of the discussion too. But, as the calendar turns to 2012, it appears that Bill O’Brien is the latest “favorite” to become the next head coach in State College.
Who?
You know. Bill O’ Brien. Of the New England Patriots. Not ringing a bell? Here is his biography and relationship to PSU:
O’Brien has no immediately apparent ties to PSU and has no head coaching experience.
He does have extensive college experience, however, which has become something of a rarity among reported Nittany Lions candidates. He’s coached at somewhat nearby Brown and Maryland, plus Duke and Georgia Tech — the latter stint included being Chan Gailey’s assistant head coach for one year.
For Penn State fans, this would have to be a major disappointment. The right-hand-man to Chan Gailey. For one year. Ugh.
Even worse, just take a look at all the coaches that were previously speculated, rumored, projected, or merely hoped for as the next coach:
- Urban Meyer (link)
- Tom Bradley (link)
- Al Golden (link)
- Mike London (link)
- Kevin Sumlin (link)
- Pat Fitzgerald (link)
- Kirk Ferentz (link)
- Dan Mullen (link). Deemed a favorite on November 29, 2011.
- Chris Petersen (link)
- Greg Schiano (link)
- Jon Gruden (link)
- Tom Clements (link)
- David Shaw (link)
- Tim Murphy (link)
- Tony Dungy (link)
- Mike Munchak (link). Deemed a favorite on December 26, 2011.
- Jay Paterno (link)
- Darren Perry (link)
- Kyle Whittingham (link)
- Mark Richt (link)
- Larry Johnson, Sr. (link)
- Bo Pelini (link)
- Brian Norwood (link)
- Mario Cristobal (link)
- Nick Saban (link)
- Eric Mangini (link)
- Bob Stoops (link)
- Bill O’Brien (link)
Again, while there are some absurd names above , there are also some very unimpressive names. Nevertheless, you don’t need Wikipedia to know who 90% of them are. Bill O’ Brien? Not a name by any stretch.
And this is not personal to Mr. O’Brien. Frankly, is it even fair for someone’s coaching debut to be at this current version of Penn State? The Nittany Lions should be looking at someone with college head coaching experience from an AQ program that can adjust to Penn State’s unique situation. Someone who knows what it takes to be a successful college coach, but is going to have to step up just to adapt to the challenge of dealing with the post-Paterno, post-scandal, PSU world. That will be challenging enough. Having it be your first head coaching job is just insane.
Moreover, the Patriots coaching tree has not exactly been successful. Of the coaches that have left recently, all have failed in their first head coaching gig. Romeo Crennel? Fired. Charlies Weis? Fired. Josh McDaniels? Fired. Eric Mangini? Fired. Not sure this is a tree worth picking these days.
Maybe O’ Brien can pull it off. Nothing is impossible. But for the neighboring ACC schools that compete for recruits with Penn State, relying on “nothing is impossible” is just fine.